Annex 2 – Guidance for the Procurement of Data
The Bank seeks to ensure compliance with metadata standards for acquired and commissioned data. To ensure that the Bank's metadata standards are consistently applied across all datasets acquired or commissioned, specific strategies must be employed depending on the source of the data. These sources include data purchased from vendors, data obtained free of charge from providers, and data collected or generated by consultants (firms or individuals) under contract. The Bank aims to maximize compliance with its metadata standards by providing templates, guidelines, and support to facilitate the adoption of these standards.
The Bank has established formal procedures and Guidance for the acquisition of development data:
Bank Procedure for Development Dataset Acquisition, Archiving and Dissemination. Procedural instructions to Bank Staff on the archiving and dissemination of development datasets and guidance on acquisition.
Bank Guidance Development Dataset Acquisition and Archiving. Guidance to Bank Staff on the acquisition and archiving of development datasets from countries, international organizations, commercial vendors, etc.
The recommendations below complement these procedures and guidance.
Data Purchased from Vendors
For data acquired through purchase agreements, the Bank must ensure that metadata accompanying the datasets meets its quality standards to facilitate responsible data use and seamless integration into internal systems.
Vendors should be required to provide datasets with full metadata, preferably structured according to a standardized template provided by the Bank. Clear instructions on metadata content, structure, and formatting must be included in the procurement documentation.
In cases where purchased data is pre-packaged with existing metadata that cannot be structured following a Bank template, the business unit who purchases the data must conduct a thorough verification to ensure that all necessary metadata elements required for responsible use are present. A checklist based on the Bank's metadata standards or templates should be used to assess the completeness and accuracy of vendor-provided metadata.
Data Obtained Free of Charge
The Bank obtains many datasets free of charge, from national statistical offices and many other partners and organizations. Some of these datasets are provided under a formal agreement with the provider, others are downloaded from these organizations’ platforms.
For datasets provided at no cost and/or online, the Bank cannot impose specific metadata requirements. However, it can in some cases encourage and support providers in adopting the Bank's standards (which comply with international best practice and align with international metadata standards) through voluntary measures:
Providers should be offered access to detailed guidelines outlining metadata best practices aligned with the Bank's standards.
Free tools should be provided to facilitate metadata structuring and formatting according to the Bank's requirements.
The Bank should highlight the benefits of metadata standardization, such as increased data discoverability and usability.
Technical assistance should be offered to help providers align their metadata with the Bank’s standards.
Even when providers do not fully comply with the recommended standards, the Bank should conduct internal reviews to identify gaps and take corrective actions, such as supplementing missing metadata elements where possible.
Data Collected or Generated for the Bank by Consultants
For datasets collected or generated under consultancy contracts, the Bank has greater control over metadata compliance. Compliance can be ensured through contractual obligations and technical support:
All contracts with consultants and consulting firms engaged in the collection, production, or acquisition of development data must include a requirement to submit metadata compliant with the Bank metadata standards. Metadata templates and specific requirements should be detailed in the terms of reference (TORs) for each project.
Consultants must be given access to standardized metadata templates and comprehensive documentation to facilitate adherence to the required standards.
Clear guidance on metadata content, structure, and formatting should be provided at the project initiation phase.
Training sessions or onboarding meetings can be arranged to ensure consultants understand metadata expectations.
A designated point of contact should be available to address queries and provide ongoing support throughout the data collection process.
Final deliverables should be assessed against the agreed metadata standards, and any deficiencies must be addressed before acceptance of the data.